
The WORD of God
RHEMA vs. LOGOS
Its
meaning and uses
by William G Dicks
-
In
the Charismatic world we have been inundated
with all kinds of teaching from all over the world. Some of it
legitimate, and others not. In the last two decades or so the teaching
has been spread that there is a major
difference between RHEMA and LOGOS. Is there a difference? If so,
what are the differences between these two words? If not, how do
they relate to each other? It has been taught that rhema
is the spoken Word from God to each individual or to a people
today, whereas logos
is God's written Word as we have it in the Bible.
One
thing that we must not be, is scared of
what our studies of the Word of God will reveal. We should also
never come to the Scriptures with preconceived ideas. We should
also not always merely accept what we are taught from the pulpit
or in conferences by "reputable" teachers. We should be like the
Bereans that kept on comparing what Paul preached with the
Scriptures they had.
In
the final analysis we are all responsible
for our own faith and system of doctrine. If we are to mature as
Christians, then we have to "be diligent to present [ourselves]
approved unto God as a workman who does not need to be
ashamed, accurately handling the word of truth." (NASB 2 Tim.
2:15). This study is not just a matter of semantics. Is it
semantics that separate us from the Jehovah's Witnesses and the
Mormons? It is the true meaning behind common words that we use.
There are many words that are shared between them, and us, yet
they have vastly different meanings. So, it is important to know
exactly what a word means as set forth in the Scriptures.
-
First,
let us look at some lexicons and a
theological dictionary.
The
following resources were used:
Strong's exhaustive concordance from the
Online Bible.
Gerhard Kittel's Theological Dictionary of
the New Testament abridged in one volume and translated by Geoffrey W.
Bromiley.
W.E. Vine's Expository dictionary of New
Testament words.
Thayer's A Greek-English lexicon of the
New Testament.
Louw and Nida's Greek-English lexicon, recognised
by many Greek scholars as one of the best works on Greek lexicography.
Bauer's A Greek-English lexicon of the New
Testament and other early Christian literature, recognised by
many Greek scholars to be the best work on Greek lexicography.
This
is what I gleaned from the above resources
about rhema.
[what
has been uttered by the living voice,
sound from the voice with a definite meaning, words joined
together to form a sentence; something expressly stated like an
announcement or treaty, the Septuagint translates both logos
and rhema from the Hebrew dabar,
that which is
uttered in speach or writing; speech, discourse, the subject
matter of speech; a minimal unit of discourse, single word, focus
on the content of the communication, differences between logos
and rhema is a matter of style; thing, expression]
This
is what I gleaned from the above resources
about logos.
[a
word, decree, the act of speaking, teaching,
reason, account; first sense of collection, counting,
conversation; expression of thought, statement; thoughts
expressed in words, relates to speaking and thinking, a divine
declaration recorded in the OT; systematic and formal treatment
of a subject, the content of what is preached; matter]
- Translation
Spoken
The following verses related
to rhema all
show its usage with the
general meaning of "speaking".
Mt
4:4; Mt 12:36; Mt 18:16; Mt 26:75; Mt 27:14;
Mr 9:32; Mr
14:72; Lu 1:38; Lu 1:65; Lu
2:17; Lu 2:19; Lu 2:29; Lu 2:50; Lu
2:51; Lu 3:2; Lu 5:5; Lu 7:1; Lu 9:45; Lu 18:34; Lu 20:26; Lu 22:61;
Lu 24:8; Lu 24:11; Joh 3:34; Joh 5:47; Joh 6:63; Joh 6:68; Joh 8:20;
Joh 8:47; Joh 10:21; Joh 12:47; Joh 12:48; Joh 14:10; Joh 15:7;
Joh 17:8; Ac 2:14; Ac 5:20; Ac 6:11; Ac 6:13; Ac 10:22; Ac 10:37;
Ac
10:44 ""While Peter was still saying these things (rhema), the Holy
Spirit fell on all who heard the word (logos). Here the logos
is equated with the rhema that
Peter
delivered unto them.
Ac
11:14; Ac 11:16; Ac 13:42; Ac 16:38; Ac 26:25;
Ac 28:25;
Ro
10:17 "So faith comes from hearing, and hearing through the word of Christ."
Should
we believe that here the rhema refers to the spoken
word?
No, here it has nothing to do with the word being a spoken word
or a written word. The word here is the gospel of Christ being
preached.
Ro
10:18; 2Co 12:4; 2Co 13:1; Heb 1:3;
Heb
11:3 "By faith we
understand that the universe was created by the word of God, so that
what is seen was not made out of things that are visible."
God
spoke and all that exist came into
existence. In 2Pe 3:5 it is the logos that was
spoken and
the heavens existed. Here it is clear that rhema and
logos
are meant to be synonyms.
Heb
12:19 "and the sound of a trumpet and a voice whose words made the
hearers beg that no further messages (logos) be spoken to
them." Here once again logos is equated with rhema.
1Pe
1:25 "'but the word
of the Lord remains forever.' And this word is the good
news that was preached to you." The rhema of
the Lord
here is the gospel that was preached.
2Pe
3:2 "that you should remember the predictions
of the holy prophets and the commandment of the Lord and Savior through
your apostles."
The
rhema
of the
prophets that
the New Testament disciples knew in those days were written, yet
they are referred to as that which was spoken by the prophets. In
this case rhema
can be seen as
referring to that which is written.
Although the prophets spoke those words, to the people that Peter
wrote to, they were written. See also Jude 1:17.
Other
than
spoken
Lu
1:37 "For nothing
(no word) will be impossible with God."
Lu
2:15; Ac 5:32;
Ro
10:8 "But what does it say? 'The word
is near you, in your mouth and in your heart' (that is, the word of faith that
we proclaim);" The word of faith being preached is
the gospel. The gospel today is part of the written Scriptures.
Should it not then be known as the logos? During
the early
years of preaching the gospel, it was not written down yet, but
the gospel is just as well contained in the OT as it is in the NT.
Anyway, the word of faith is preached here and not written.
Eph
5:26 "that he might sanctify her, having cleansed her by the washing of
water with the word,"
Here there is no reason to go either way as to what rhema
is referring to. It could be pointing to the gospel that is
cleansing us, or to the whole of the Bible that has a sanctifying
effect on us.
Eph
6:17 "and take the helmet of salvation, and the sword of the Spirit,
which is the word
of God," Is the sword of the Spirit that which is spoken or
that which is written, or both? Something that I just thought of
is this: Do the Scriptures refer to that which God has spoken or
to that which is written when it uses the phrase word
of
God? I am almost sure that it uses the former meaning. Whether it
uses the phrase rhema of God, or logos
of God, it
still points to that which is spoken.
Heb
6:5 "and have tasted the goodness of the word of God and the
powers of the age to come," In the context the
Scriptures are speaking about salvation and related subjects, and
I would venture to say that in this case "word of
God"
refers to the gospel as that which is good.
For
the sake of time and space we will not
display all instances of logos or its derivatives
which
amount to about 320. Selected verses will be used here.
In
the gospels logos is used as a spoken
word in the greatest majority of cases. We can learn from this
that logos is not to be interpreted as that which
is
written alone. It is to be suggested that the word used to refer
to the written word of God is graphe. When a
reference is
made to logos as that which is written and
especially when
a quote is made from the Old Testament, is seems never to show
the whole of the Old Testament as the logos, but
rather a
book or even just a verse. e.g. Lu 3:4 "As it is written in the book of
the words
of Isaiah the prophet, 'The voice of one crying in the wilderness:
"Prepare the way of the Lord, make his paths straight."'", Joh 12:38
"so that the word
spoken by the prophet Isaiah might be fulfilled: 'Lord, who has
believed what he heard from us, and to whom has the arm of the Lord
been revealed?'", Joh 15:25 "But the word that is written
in their Law must be fulfilled: 'They hated me without a cause.'"
Spoken
Mt
5:37; Mt 7:24; Mt 7:28; Mt 8:8; Mt 8:16; Mt
10:14; Mt 12:32; Mt 12:36; Mt 13:19; Mt 15:12; Mt 15:23; Mt 21:24;
Mt 22:15; Mt 24:35; Mt 26:44; Mr 5:36; Mr 8:38; Mr 10:24; Lu 1:20;
Lu 4:22; Lu 4:36; Lu 5:15; Lu 6:47; Lu 9:28; Lu 10:39; Lu 23:9;
Joh
2:22 "When therefore he was raised from the dead, his disciples
remembered that he had said this, and they believed the Scripture (graphe) and the word that Jesus had
spoken." Here John uses the word graphe to
refer to
the written Scriptures, and logos to refer to that
which
Jesus had spoken.
Joh
4:39; Joh 4:50;
Joh 14:23-24 "Jesus answered him, "If anyone loves me, he will
keep my word,
and my Father will love him, and we will come to him and make our home
with him. Whoever does not love me does not keep my words. And the word that you hear
is not mine but the Father's who sent me." John is not
using logos here as that which is written, but
rather as
those words that Jesus spoke to the disciples.
Joh
17:6 "I have
manifested your name to the people whom you gave me out of the world.
Yours they were, and you gave them to me, and they have kept your word."
Verse 14 will clear up what the logos here refers
to. It
refers to that which Jesus spoke to them.
Joh
17:14 "I have given them your word,
and the world has hated them because they are not of the world, just as
I am not of the world."
Joh
17:20;
Joh
18:9 "This was to fulfill the word
that he had spoken:" Logos here refers to a portion
of the
Scriptures, and not all the Scriptures.
Joh
18:32; Ac 2:22; Ac 2:40;
Ac
4:4 "But many of those who had heard the word believed, and
the number of the men came to about five thousand." Logos
here refers to the gospel as
preached by the apostles, and not all the Scriptures.
Ac
5:5;
Ac
10:44 "While Peter was still saying these things (rhema) , the
Holy Spirit fell on all who heard the word." These words (rhema)
of Peter were
seen as a logos. Here we have a direct equation
between
these two words.
Ac
11:22; Ac 13:15; Ac 15:27; Ro 3:4;
Ro
9:6 "But it is not as though the word
of God has failed. For not all who are descended from Israel belong to
Israel," The word of God here
most probably refers to the promises God made to Israel. In verse
9 the word is shown as the promise to Abraham.
Ro
9:9 "For this is what the promise said:
'About this time next year I will return and Sarah shall have a son.'"
Ro
13:9; Ro 14:12; 1Co 1:5; 1Co 1:18; 1Co 4:20;
1Co
12:8 "To one is given through the Spirit the utterance of wisdom,
and to another the utterance
of knowledge according to the same Spirit," One of the most
conclusive evidences that rhema does not refer to
the
spoken word and logos to the
written word is
found here in this passage where logos is used to
refer to
the spoken word as found in the logos
of wisdom,
and the logos of knowledge. It has been said so
many times
by popular preachers that the word of wisdom, the word
of knowledge, and prophecy are to be seen as the rhema
of
God to His people, yet here in this passage it is clear that they
are the logos of God.
1Co
14:9;
1Co
14:19 "Nevertheless, in church I would rather speak five words with my mind
in order to instruct others, than ten thousand words in a tongue."
When speaking in a tongue it is not a rhema from
God,
but a logos from God.
1Co
15:2; 1Co 15:54; 2Co 1:18; 2Co 10:11; 2Co
11:6; Ga 5:14; Ga 6:6; Eph 4:29; Eph 5:6; Eph 6:19; Col 3:17; Col
4:6; 1Th 1:5; 1Th 4:18; 2Th 3:14; 1Ti 4:12; 1Ti 6:3; 2Ti 1:13;
Tit 2:8;
Heb
2:2 "For since the message
declared by angels proved to be reliable and every transgression or
disobedience received a just retribution," Here the logos is spoken by angels.
Heb
4:2; Heb 7:28;
Heb
12:19 "and the sound of a trumpet and a voice whose words (rhema) made
the hearers beg that no further messages
be spoken to them."
Again, here the logos is equated with the rhema
that was spoken.
Heb
13:22; Jas 3:2; 1Pe 3:15;
2Pe
3:5 "For they
deliberately overlook this fact, that the heavens existed long ago, and
the earth was formed out of water and through water by the word of God, . . . 7
But by the same word
the heavens and earth that now exist are stored up for fire, being kept
until the day of judgment and destruction of the ungodly." When God
spoke the
heavens into existence, the Scriptures do not use the word rhema,
but rather logos. What does this show us? When God
speaks
we cannot make a difference between rhema and
logos.
1Jo
3:18; Re 12:11.
Other
than
spoken
The
gospel
Lu
8:11 "Now the parable is this: The seed is the word of
God. (12) The ones along the path are those who
have heard. Then the devil comes and takes away the word from their
hearts, so that they may not believe and be saved."
I would suggest that logos here refers to the
gospel,
because it is by this logos that "they may [ ]
believe and be saved."
Joh
5:38 "and you do not have his word
abiding in you, for you do not believe the one whom he has sent." Jesus
said
this to the Pharisees because they did not accept the good news
about Jesus, "for whom he sent, him ye believe not."
The word here then refers to the good news about
Jesus
that they did not want to accept, and therefore did not abide in
them. For, if it was, they would have believed in Jesus.
Joh
8:31 "So Jesus said to the Jews who had believed in him, "If you abide
in my word,
you are truly my disciples," Jesus did not have any technical
meaning for logos except to say that in order to be
a
disciple of His, one has to "continue in My word." (NASB
Updated edition) This word then points to the
gospel that
Jesus brought to them. It is a word that Jesus
spoke to
them from the times of His own baptism.
Ac
6:2 "And the twelve summoned the full number of the disciples and said,
'It is not right that we should give up preaching the word of God to serve
tables.'"
The logos here again refers to the gospel, and not
to all
the Scriptures. When we keep on reading we can see what the
twelve meant by the word of God in verse 4, "But we
will devote ourselves to prayer and to the ministry of the word."
The gospel is intended here.
Ac
6:4;
Ac
6:7 "And the word
of God continued to increase, and the number of the disciples
multiplied greatly in Jerusalem, and a great many of the priests became
obedient to the faith." How does the word of God
increase, unless it means that the gospel kept on spreading.
Ac
8:4 "Now those who were scattered went about preaching the word." I would
suggest that the word here again refers to the
gospel.
Ac
8:14; Ac 8:25; Ac 10:36; Ac 11:1; Ac 12:24;
Ac 13:5; Ac 15:7;Ac 15:35; Ac 16:6;
Ac
17:11 "Now these Jews were more noble than those in Thessalonica; they
received the word
with all eagerness, examining the Scriptures (graphe) daily to see
if these things were so." In this instance the logos
is set in contrast to the written Scriptures.
Ac
19:20; 1Co 14:36; 2Co 2:17; 2Co 5:19; 2Co 6:7;
Eph 1:13; Php 1:14; Php 2:16; Col 1:5; Col 1:25; Col 3:16; Col 4:3;
1Th 1:6; 1Th 1:8; 1Th 2:13; 2Th 3:1; Tit 1:3; Tit 1:9; Heb 5:13;
Heb 6:1; Heb 13:7; Jas 1:18; 1Pe 1:23; 1Pe 2:8; 1Pe 1:23; 1Pe 2:8;
Re 6:9.
Other
Mt
5:32;
Mt
15:6 "So for the sake of your tradition you have made void the word of God."
In
this case the logos of God may refer
to the whole of the Bible, but I would suggest that in the
context in this case logos refers to the
commandments
given by Moses to the Israelites. In verse 3 Jesus asks them
"why do you break the commandment of God for the sake of your
tradition?", and then Jesus quotes one of
the commandments.
Mt
18:23; Mr 1:45;
Lu
3:4 "As it is written in the book of the words of Isaiah the
prophet." Here the written part that logos
refers to is that verse which Luke quotes here, and not the whole
of the Bible as the "written word of God."
Joh
1:1 "In the beginning was the Word,
and the Word
was with God, and the Word
was God."
Here logos undeniably refers to Jesus as in the
following
verse. Joh 1:14 "And the Word
became flesh and dwelt among us, and we have seen his glory, glory as
of the only Son from the Father, full of grace and truth."
Joh
12:38 "But the word
that is written in their Law must be fulfilled." Again, here word
refers to a portion of
the OT found in Isaiah.
Joh
15:25 "But the word
that is written in their Law must be fulfilled: 'They hated me without
a cause.'" Logos here
refers to a portion of the law, and not all the Scriptures.
Ac
1:1 "In the first book,
O Theophilus, I have dealt with all that Jesus began to do and teach." Logos
here refers to that which Luke wrote
before, yet it only refers to the book of Luke and not the whole
of the Bible.
Ac
15:15; Ac 19:40;
Ro
9:28 "for the Lord will carry out his sentence upon the
earth fully and without delay."
Isaiah is here quoted saying that the Lord will execute His logos
quickly. What was Isaiah referring to if indeed his own
prophecies were part of written Scripture? Is it logical here to
say that the logos refers to the written word?
Logos
most likely refers to a portion of Scripture, or even the spoken word
of God.
2Co
4:2; Php 4:15; Php 4:17; Col 2:23;
1Th
4:15 "For this we declare to you by a
word
from the Lord, that we who are alive, who are left until the coming of
the Lord, will not precede those who have fallen asleep." The word
of the Lord here probably refers to
that which the Lord revealed to Paul, and is not written
somewhere else.
1Ti
4:5; 1Ti 5:17; 2Ti 2:9; 2Ti 2:15; 2Ti 4:2;
Tit 2:5; Heb 4:12; Jas 1:21-23; 1Pe 3:1; 2Pe 1:19; 1Jo 1:10; 1Jo
2:5; 1Jo 2:14; Re 1:2; Re 3:8; Re 17:17; Re 19:9; Re 22:7.
- The
phrases "Word of God" and "Word of the Lord"
Word
of God
Lu
3:2 - God spoke to John the Baptist in the
wilderness.
Eph
6:17 - The sword of the Spirit.
Heb
6:5 - Tasting the good word of God.
Heb
11:3 - The worlds were prepared by the word
of God.
Word
of the
Lord
Lu
22:61 - Peter remembered the word of the
Lord about the rooster.
Ac
11:16 - Peter remembered the word of the
Lord concerning the Holy Spirit.
1Pe
1:25 - The word of the Lord endures
forever; the gospel is this word.
Word
of God
Mt
15:6 - The word of God being invalidated by
the traditions of men.
Lu
8:11 - The seed that is sown is the word of
God.
Ac
6:2 - The apostles are not to serve tables
with the effect of neglecting the word of God (the preaching of
the gospel).
Ac
6:7 - The word of God (the gospel) kept on
spreading.
Ac
8:14 - Samaria received the word of God (the
gospel).
Ac
11:1 - The Gentiles received the word of God
(the gospel).
Ac
12:24 - The word of God (the gospel)
continued to grow.
Ac
13:5 - They began to proclaim the word of
God (the gospel).
Ro
9:6 - The word of God concerning Israel did
not fail.
1Co
14:36 - How did they get to know about the
word of God (the gospel).
2Co
2:17 - Many peddle the word of God (the
gospel).
2Co
4:2 - Not adulterating the word of God (the
gospel).
Php
1:14 - Speaking the word of God (the gospel)
without fear.
Col
1:25 - Paul was called to carry out the
word of God (the gospel).
1Th
2:13 - The Thessalonians received the word
of God (the gospel).
1Ti
4:5 - Foods are sanctified by means of the
word of God and prayer.
2Ti
2:9 - The word of God (the gospel) is not
imprisoned.
Tit
2:5 - The word of God (the gospel) must not
be dishonored.
Heb
4:12 - The word of God is living and active.
Heb
13:7 - Remember those who led you and spoke
the word of God to you.
1Pe
1:23 - We are born again through the living
and enduring word of God (the gospel).
2Pe
3:5 - It is by the word of God (God spoke)
that the heavens existed long ago.
1Jo
2:14 - The word of God abides in the young
men.
Re
1:2 - John testified to the word of God.
Re
6:9 - Some were slain because of the word of
God (the gospel).
Word
of the
Lord
Ac
8:25 - They testified and spoke the word of
the Lord.
Ac
15:35 - Paul and Barnabas taught and
preached the word of the Lord.
Ac
19:20 - The word of The Lord (the gospel)
grew mightily.
1Th
1:8 - The word of the Lord (the gospel)
sounded forth from the Thessalonians.
1Th
4:15 - Paul spoke to them by the word of
the Lord.
2Th
3:1 - Thessalonians were to pray for Paul
that word of the Lord (the gospel) would spread rapidly.
- Conclusion
After
what we have learnt concerning the uses
of rhema and logos, we have to
conclude that there
is no reason for us to speak of rhema as the spoken
word
of God, and of logos as the written word
of God.
Both have the potential to be used in either way. It has become
one of the Charismatic ways to bring in all kinds of unverified
teachings that no-one bothers to study. If it ever happens that
someone differs on something they feel is essential to their
Charismania, they will come with counter attacks such as "you
are not in submission to your elders", "you are
critical", and "do not resist God's anointed", etc.
Many Charismatic churches are still in the trap of believing that
whatever the pastor says must be adhered to, because you need to
remain under someone's covering. This is what I would liken unto
Charismatic witchcraft. Witchcraft is the art of manipulation,
and boy, do these Charismatics manipulate! Do not get me wrong! I
am a Charismatic (Reformed/Calvinistic) myself, but I am daring to
stand up and be
counted for correct doctrine. I want to handle the word
of
truth correctly. We cannot do this unless we study the Scriptures
for ourselves. We are to be mature Christians, and not just be
spoonfed from the pulpit. Ultimately we are each responsible for
our own spiritual lives.
My
purpose for writing this paper was not to
trample on toes, or to deviate from that which is the truth.
Rather, it is a calling back to that which is the truth. How many
times have we not heard that someone said, "I received a
rhema from God last night." It is accepted to such a large
extent - not truthfully - that there exists a major difference
between rhema and logos, that
it almost seems
impossible that people's perception would be changed. Who wants
to stand up and say "All of you are wrong, and I am right."
The sheer opposition to that would already put most people off.
Yet, when we know that there is wrong teaching in the church we
need to stand up and speak the truth the best we know how.
After
all this rambling, what is the connection
between rhema and logos? One
thing I have found is
that rhema is never used to point to a quotation in
the OT
in the same way that logos is used. E.g. Joh. 12:38
"that
the word of Isaiah the prophet might be fulfilled,
which
he spake, …" Logos is used in this way
several
times where such a quotation from the OT is made, but never do we
find any conclusive proof that logos is directly
connected
with the whole of the Bible. Rather logos is used
as a
part of a book or as a word. Looking at all the
passages
quoted above that relate to both rhema and logos
we
have to conclude that these 2 words are in reality synonyms for
each other. As with all synonyms the "synonomic" (just
coined) words do not always have exactly the same meanings or domains.
There
could be different shades or nuances, but synonyms, nevertheless.
I
hope this study brought you, the reader, some
enlightenment, and that I was able to bring the facts across
clearly, and without ambiguity.
May
God bless you as keep on searching for, and
living out the truth.
Copyright
© 2001-2007 [Sovereign Truth]. All rights reserved.
No part of this document may be
reproduced in any form whatsoever for financial gain, or in any
commercial product whatsoever without the consent of Sovereign
Truth.
However, this document may be reproduced in
non-commercial products, such as church bulletins, e-mail
distribution lists, etc if this copyright section is included or if
credit is
given to Sovereign Truth and the author.
Contact us.
Revised: January 19, 2007
.
|